Listening to Wonderkids, the string-laden opener of Take That’s new album, it seems the three remaining fiftysomething boybanders are feeling reflective. “Forgiving you, forgiving me / This vicious circle is now complete,” sings Gary Barlow.

In the years since their last record, the band – and former member Robbie Williams – have indeed laid out the trials and tribulations of 35 years of Take That in several documentaries, some more candid than others. Earlier this year, they even embarked on a revival of their blockbuster 2009 Circus tour. Unfortunately, all this reminiscing has left their 10th album feeling so steeped in nostalgia that any moments of greatness struggle for attention.

There’s pallid disco revivalism on Best Heartbreak and Higher, the latter more S Club 7 than Dua Lipa, while guitar-bothering folk stomper Feel My Love is so tired you wonder if they still think Mumford & Sons are hip young gunslingers. Then there are the ballads: Who Do You Think You Are is lovely, with its finger-clicking, wounded lounge singer lilt, but Mark Owens’ raspy My Love Is Yours is the band’s weakest song in years.

When it’s good it’s really good: Wonderkids is genuinely stirring, Sweet July is like Shine’s sleazy little sibling and the galloping Change of Season is so delightfully strange it proves Take That could push themselves should they want to. But given they’re rolling out a vintage tour to pay the bills, Dreamers suggests they don’t.

Extracted and lightly reformatted for readability. · Source: en